Thursday, November 5, 2009

Dear friends,

Yes, it has been a very long time since I updated. I am ashamed, and you are angry. I never meant for this to happen. To appease your requests, I am posting a reflection I just wrote for my Christian Spirituality class in response to how my technology fast went. For those of you who don't know, I was required to fast for one week from email, facebook, text messaging, and the use of my cell phone outside of the home.

I don't like to post things that are more formal in nature, but this is quite anecdotal, so it's not too far of a cry from a normal post. So happy reading, and I hope to be back to blogging for real soon.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

My final moments with my cell phone looming, I sent the following text message to the Duke freshman football player for whom I serve as an academic mentor: “Hey, I won’t be able to use texting or email for a week, so if you need something you’re going to have to call me. It’s for class.” As per the texting etiquette of a 19-year-old boy, I received the following illuminating response: “lol WTF?” When I talked to him later that week, he expressed further how appalled he was and articulated repeatedly that he would never take that class. “How can you do anything on the weekends? I would freak.” I looked at him; was there any sense in trying to educate this young man about the potential evils technology poses to communication as we once knew it? I looked at the guys on his team—sitting in their players’ lounge with the plasma screens and gaming systems, cell phones in hand and iPods on hip—probably not. I said nothing more.

Later that week, I went to my job, where I sit in a small room with fourteen Duke freshmen and call alumni and ask for their money. Somewhat ironically, as I sat amidst the rows of computers and telephones, my supervisor asked me with a slight smile, “So, are you still fasting from technology?” As we chatted briefly, it came out that the class I was doing this for was Christian Spirituality. “And why?” All of a sudden, I felt my cheeks redden as I stammered in front of a suddenly silent room of students with unknown religious backgrounds a rationale for why fasting from technology was relevant to Christian Spirituality. I may have muttered key words such as “dependence” and “suffering of Christ,” but I mostly tried to divert the attention from “the odd divinity student in the room, who is offering theological musings” back to the normal routine of the evening. It was at this point that I realized that my fast was opening doors of communication that I did not feel entirely eager to pursue. I mean, I welcome my student or my co-workers to glance over my witty “religious views” on facebook, but having a conversation is perhaps going too far. “Please, I am not that kind of divinity student. No, not in a terribly pretentious kind of way; I just have no ‘seed-planting inclination’ to bring into this relationship.” Indeed, the space had opened for communication—the kind where people even look one another in the eye—and unfamiliar with this sort of interaction at Duke, where I am usually allowed to remain faceless, I tried quickly to cover the space once more.

Now, I hadn’t started my fast with such an unimpressive ability to communicate in the real world. In fact, my very first day of the fast would gradually lead me to new levels of engagement with neighbors whom I didn’t regularly talk to or had never met. However, although the day would afford really meaningful opportunities I would not have had otherwise, I was also heading to a moment I would have to shamefully include in my reflection. Indeed, as happy as my discoveries would be that day, I would also break my fast—on the first day—nineteen times.

As it happened, it was Sunday afternoon, and my roommate and her boyfriend were very loudly enjoying lunch before he had to do something heroic, like head back to the military. Enamored as I perhaps should have been with their expressions of affection, I was annoyed. I was further annoyed because I had decided to fast from online radio, which I use instead of an iPod, so I could not drown out their incessant banter. Thus, unable to hide myself in my social networks, I decided to try the Southern thing. I arranged myself on the porch for a long session of tea, blankets, and books. It was cold. Nonetheless, I convinced myself that between what the house had to offer and what the porch had to offer, the porch was the more pleasant option.

Within minutes, my similarly-aged, smooth-talking neighbor, Marian, came out his front door, holding high a bottle. “Sara! “Would you like to join me for a glass of wine?” “Now that’s the kind of Southern hospitality I’m talking about!” I put the book down. He poured, we drank, and we conversed long past the point when the wine had taken the chill out of the air. After an hour or so of talking about roommates and the nuances of our beverage, he asked about my technology fast, I asked him if he went to church, and we began discussing Marian’s religious pluralism and notions of being “spiritual, but not religious.” And, for one of the first times in my life, I felt as though I was able to articulate my answers to his challenges, as well as my own hints of faith and belief, in a decently respectable way. “Is this…ministry?”

All of a sudden, another neighbor and my roommate came over (sans boyfriend). Then we were traipsing over to meet two more neighbors we had not met. Finally, I found myself in the house next door being shown “Michael’s meditation room,” feeling euphoric about the day’s unique twist of events, and standing in front of a mantle featuring pictures of various eastern mystic leaders and pensive-looking Hindu women. I made a mental note to thank my roommate for being annoying. Since I had been unable to resort to my usual means of technology for both the solace and noise-blocking benefits, I had gone outside and met my neighbors. They had shared some of their spiritual inclinations, I had shared some of mine, and it had been wonderful. However, throughout the Sunday afternoon festivities, smooth-talking Marian had mysteriously kept my wine glass full, and by the end of it all, I no longer much cared that I was fasting from technology, and I found myself sending nineteen text messages, as I told several friends about my exciting day. After that, my week then turned into a self-imposed “technology and wine fast.” Since I was only a half a day into the fast, I really could have just started over after my failure, but I knew that the experience that had led to my lapse in attentiveness was necessary to preserve as part of the whole technology fast experience, and so I continued.

After such a grand kick-off to the fast, the rest of the week unfolded in a much more mundane way. I caught myself grabbing for my phone when it wasn’t there, and I realized that one of the primary uses of the phone is that it provides comfort. When I walked down that especially long divinity school hallway, I could no longer pretend I was doing something very important on my phone, in an attempt to avoid the always awkward eye contact games. I had to stare at the ground until the person was ten feet away, and then casually glance in his direction to determine whether or not we would be exchanging pleasantries, just like people used to have to do. Moreover, I realized that facebook helps me enormously in knowing what is going on in my friends’ lives. I may not really need to know that former high school classmate, Leanne, “Is Havin the WROst Day EVER!!”, but even if we never talk about it, I feel closer to Bethy in Michigan when I know that she “would like her sermon to write itself.” Sure, I could take the time for phone calls and lunch dates to catch up on friends’ lives, but when time and/or location make that impossible, at least I know that Ashlea is thinking of me by “liking” my self-deprecatory status about wanting to shank myself with a rusty spoon. As stated further by Lenora Rand in “The Church on Facebook”: “Facebook allows us to remain intimate and honest, to know each other and be known by each other, even if that isn't happening in the bricks-and-mortar world.” Indeed, people tend to be more honest online, allowing themselves to reach out and be reached out to, when perhaps they would not do so otherwise.

Some aspects of the fast really were very life-giving. Needing a new method of procrastination, I began to read the world news. I read about the violence in world cities, and then I perused a map to solidify the locations of these cities in my head. Instead of actually being on facebook, I read several articles about the beginning and continual developments of facebook. Additionally, not only was I learning perhaps more substantial things than I would have reading my facebook news feed, I was also getting more homework done than usual. I was reminded of the time I spent studying abroad in England last spring, without the use of a cell phone. I was allowed to sit in the coffee shop on High Street all day, with no one to bother me except myself (and perhaps the voice of my tutor in my head). My mind was free to go in whatever direction it desired, and there was no phone vibrating in my pocket to interrupt it. Although our technology may point us in millions of exciting directions, it also seems to stifle the creativity that is fostered by real time alone to think.

On the other hand, repercussions did arise because of the fast. I did not sign up for a pre-registration advising appointment because I did not get the email. I missed my father’s birthday, because I could not look at the reminder my mother texted me that day. Lastly, I received a deduction on my Into Great Silence reflection after making a very conscious decision that making an exception to email my paper in by noon would be contrary to the spirit of the fast. Instead, my completed paper remained tucked in my folder until class. I now realize that I should have arranged some kind of face-to-face handoff earlier in the week, but I also am struck that for the first time in my life, I managed to transcend my focus on what I needed to do for the grade in order to stay faithful to what it meant to truly engage in the assignment. Thus, I learned what was uncomfortable and annoying about lacking communication, but I also learned that the discomfort itself has life-giving potential.

By the end of the week, the rationale I had given my supervisor for why fasting from technology was relevant to Christian Spirituality had not entered the reality of my week. In my own perceived sufferings, I had done no reflecting on the sufferings of Christ. Although I had come to an awareness of my usually unnecessary dependence on technology, I had done no reflecting on how such dependence might infringe upon my dependence on God. What I had realized was that the fast had opened the doors of communication for me many times—regarding both spirituality and the ways we communicate—and I had the opportunity to respond in more than 140 characters. Perhaps I didn’t always know how to do so adequately, but I am convinced that looking someone in the eye while giving a mediocre articulation of your convictions is far better than even the most clever religious views on facebook. It might be cool for my friend to exhort me with a tagline in blue letters to “Follow the Crucified and Risen Jewish Criminal,” but it really is far cooler to talk to Marian on his porch or stand in Michael’s meditation room. Sure, the church may find ways to have effective facebook prayer chains or revolutionary worship experiences with twitter, but at the same time, we all embody our spirituality in a way that begs for us to communicate with real bodily presence. For when we realize that ideas inhabit people and not cyberspace, we further realize that there is value and worth in these people that can’t be communicated through an online profile. To really know and understand the people in our lives, we must seek to know them holistically, and that means that as the body of Christ, we must continue to communicate by looking one another in the eye.

12 comments:

  1. I want to fly to North Carolina and drink wine on your porch.
    Thanks for making my day, Sara!

    ReplyDelete
  2. This was really quite lovely. My favorite: "Although our technology may point us in millions of exciting directions, it also seems to stifle the creativity that is fostered by real time alone to think."

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for this, kitten. If I didn't have to buy food, I'd totally come visit you ASAP.

    ReplyDelete
  4. oh my goodness. i love it. and i want to send it to my "Embodiment" professor (my fav. class ever) cuz its stuff we've talked about. Especially the last paragraph :) And...i'm glad my fb status could forever be ingrained in cyber space for it now appears on fb AND on your highly read blog.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Lauren Winner will now probably have a crush on you and not me. And her website is terribly out of date. You should talk to her about that.

    ReplyDelete
  6. At least we all know why you ignored our texts.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great thoughts-thanks for sharing.

    How many people found this post because you posted on facebook that you updated your blog?

    How are you moving on from this experience and incorporating what you learned? Is your fast still impacting how much you use facebook? What does that look like?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great post. Mostly because you used the word "perused."

    ReplyDelete
  9. Sara, Well done. Thanks for sharing this.
    I'll echo Steve, who asked about what this experience means for you moving forward. Thoughts on that?

    Also, I though this was interesting:
    by Lenora Rand in “The Church on Facebook”: “Facebook allows us to remain intimate and honest, to know each other and be known by each other, even if that isn't happening in the bricks-and-mortar world.”

    I generally find that most of my FB friends are always saying how great their lives are...or sharing incredibly superficial aspects of their days. It doesn't seem "intimate and honest". Maybe I just have lame FB friends...(present company excluded, of course).

    ReplyDelete
  10. In response to Jennie and Steve:

    I have not made any drastic changes since the fast. I perhaps text less, because I realized how meaningless my messages usually are. That's the thing about seminary, though, there are always things to think about and ways to change your life. I wrote a sincere paper on the importance of keeping the Sabbath, even though I knew I would not start keeping the Sabbath. Then I write a paper on this technology fast, without planning to make any changes. Does this mean I'm an awful, terrible person? Probably yes. Does this mean I didn't learn anything? No. I learned plenty. This is where I should resolve my thoughts, but I don't know how to resolve them.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This is kind of awesome. I kind of wish I could detox from technology for a while, but this is unlikely because (a) I'd get fired and (b) I'd probably have a meltdown. I NEED to be connected. I don't know why. I don't even particularly like half the people I involuntarily become connected to. But, it's better than being alone.

    It's an interesting theory - are people more honest online? Yes and no. I think it's a mix. Someone else commented and said people only posted the best things. This is true. It's a psychological phenomenon called "image management" or some such (hey, I'm an old lady and I've been out of school for almost THREE YEARS now.. holy crap. That just freaked me out. THREE YEARS. damn.) where was I? Yes. It's easier to manage our image online because we can choose what people see. So Joe Smith might look happy and successful but nobody can see that he lost his job and his house got foreclosed on, because he obviously would choose not to broadcast that information. We are definitely losing touch on the reality of people.

    I read a while back an article that had a similar premise - the author assumed that he/she (I don't even remember) was on top and aware of the goings-on of their friends' lives because of their updates on facebook. Then they actually had a phone conversation or met up and they found out that one of their friends was having a really rough time, and they never would have known it otherwise, because they were keeping things off the radar so people wouldn't worry. So, the moral of the story was: unplug and actually talk to the people in your life.

    People, yes, are honest, to a degree. It's hard to fake things on the internet because inevitably people will find out if you are a phony. BUT, to a larger degree, people are liars. And it's a lie of omission. They conveniently leave out the bad and only show the good, and it makes them look good.

    I do this, I am guilty of this. I do a good deal of bitching and the like, I don't claim to be all sunshine and sparkly unicorns or whatever. But I also think very carefully about what I show, and what image that will project. (Hey, I WAS a graphic designer, once. The message is the key. Always, to everything. What is the message? That, is your focus.) I don't post pictures where I have more than a chin and a half, I maybe sort of photoshop them first. Only the best foot forward. I wouldn't hesitate to announce if something great happened, like a promotion, but I'd be much more weary of posting something negative, like a layoff. It's a skewed reality, is what we see.

    Dammit I should just go write my own damn blog post so I'm not taking up all your space. If I do, I'll link back to you.

    I think this is a really interesting experiment and I would love to hear more about it, if you have more to say... if not, this was pretty awesome and clearly set my brain in motion.

    You INSPIRE me, Sara. (yes, that was meant to be as cheesy as it sounds.)

    ReplyDelete